I'm stuck between Cashmere and Brighten Up are they A LOT alike? Which one is better for a light skin and light eyes complexion?

Cashmere is a matte pale bisque.
Brighten Up (not warm up) is a warm matte cream.
To clarify, Cashmere is a little darker than Brighten Up. Also Cashmere has of a pinkish tone to it, where Brighten Up is more golden than pink in tone.